I’m still working on the final spindle (motor) for the Pleasant Mill.
As mentioned before, the Dremel as spindle motor works more or less fine, but it’s way too loud for my ears! That’s why I bought a big-ass brushless motor back in mid-2011 as kickoff for a new, self-made spindle.
I found this blog post (Google translation) on a DIY spindle and decided to use it as base for my build. I even found a PDF with detailed drawings of such a spindle on this site (Google translation).
So the build began:
I bought a piece of V2A steel stock on ebay and machined the spindle body on my lathe. It was the first time for me to machine steel. Definitely a whole different deal than the aluminum and brass stock I work with normally…
The main work was to drill the 17mm through boring into the V2A. Here’re the tools I used for this job (from left to right):
After the tough job of drilling the hole, the bearing seats were machined with the boring bar:
I hadn’t a thread cutter tool for machining inner 19mm fine pitch threads a the time. So I paused the project until the ordered tools were delivered…
Still missing the inner thread:
The 6001 ball bearings fit. However, I later replaced the RS type bearings with Z type bearings.
And that’s my trash can after boring the V2A stock:
A week later or so, the thread cutting tool arrived. Here’s the spindle housing with the fine pitch thread. The threaded ring later holds the bearing in place. It’s made out of aluminum.
The rest of the assembly. I bought the ER11 100mm spindle on ebay. The only modification was the flattening at it’s end for fastening the timing wheel with the set screw.
The distance rings were machined out of brass by me. The timing wheel’s center hole was re-bored to fit on the spindle shaft and a set screw was added.
Here’s the lower part of the spindle after assembly. The lower brass distance ring is also visible:
And the upper part of the assembly. Again, a brass distance ring sits between ball bearing and the rest of the assembly: timing wheel, another brass spacer and finally a washer and a bolt. The spacer and bold are for adding some pretension (“Vorspannung”, not sure if this is the correct word for it in English) on the bearings.
Finally, I machined an eccentric ring for mounting the motor in the retainer clamp. By rotating the eccentric ring, the disance between spindle and motor axis can be varied by some mm to adjust the tension of the timing belt.
I’m not particularly proud of the retainer clamp itself. I tried to build it from 10mm sheet aluminum without proper tools. This resulted kind of a “substandard” piece on the whole assembly. As soon as I can get access to the proper tools, I’ll build a better, cleaner version of the clamp…
Anyhow, here’s the complete spindle with the 2.5kW 1000KV brushless motor:
The motor is most likely oversized for this. But i thought it would be a good idea to run motor and speed controller (ESC) way under their ratings in order to run both for much longer time as they usually do in their RC world habitat.
And then the real problems start: How to run such a motor not from LiPo batteries but from a power supply?! I read all kinds of warnings on this in the internet. There were some guys, saying it would be ok to simply connect a brushless motor with it’s ESC to a power supply, but a lot other guys saying that the power supply won’t last for long.
Since I didn’t want to blow up my high current power supply by connecting an RC world ESC to it, and also since I read, that running a brushless motor without hall sensors won’t work very well with quick changing loads on the motor, I started to develop my own brushless speed controller, using three hall sensors I added to the motor’s housing for closed loop operation. The power stage is driven by an Arduino. I’ll write some more details on this in my next post.
Meanwhile I bought a smaller brushed DC motor on ebay. This motor has a rotary encoder already mounted to it’s end, so I thought, it would be nice to try some PID speed controlled spindle driving with it.
One problem was, that the motor’s spindle has a diameter of only 4mm while the timing wheels all have a 6mm center hole. So I machined a special spindle adapter out of brass:
I also needed a second eccentric ring for the motor retainer:
With the new DC motor I was finally able to use the spindle for the first time. It worked well and was considerably quieter than using a Dremel as spindle motor.
However, the brushed DC motor is definitely too weak for the job. I used it to drill holes in a PCB, but only for the smaller drills. Drilling the 3mm mounting holes in the corners of the PCB failed (the spindle simply stopped…).
Here’s a video of the brushed DC spindle in action. The video also compares the sound level of my former Dremel spindle to the new spindle:
Quick question, how did you end up powering the Brushless motor? I’m scratching up my own designs at the moment, and I’ve run into that same issue.
I have a prototype of the driver which is more or less working. However, I still need to tweak the schematics and PCB on this one (and currently don’t have too much time next to my daytime job). As soon as the driver is working reliable I’ll definitely publish it’s schematics here on the blog.
Here’s the current state of the schematics as PDF. It works so far, but the MOSFETs aren’t the correct type yet. I.e. you shouldn’t take these schematics as a final working product!!
Awesome, what power supply are you using?
It’s a 12V/30A switching power supply.
Ah, but what about the 1.5kW brushless motor?
The motor is rated for 1.5kW, but I’m sure it’s not a good idea to actually run it at that power rating for longer than a few minutes. As inexpensive these RC type of motors are, the problem with them is that they aren’t made for long time load at the rated maximum power. The battery of a RC model normally last only for 10 minutes or so. A CNC mill most likely runs much longer without pauses. So I guess its a good practice to run the motor at only around half of it’s rating. I wouldn’t need so much power on such a small mill anyway and getting a power supply more than 30A isn’t easy and definitely not cheap…
Hats’ off. I have a similar idea for a mill that I’m brewing inside my head for now.
I’m curious- have you measured TIR for this spindle?
Awesome. I’m on the same setup. Almost the same.
I’m using a 3kw water cooling brushless from hobbyking and a 190A ESC. A servo tester to control the speed (acting like throttle channel). Also I’ll use a GV-1 governor to see the actual speed.
The real problem is to find a good power supply for it because the machine will run for hours and the stock material will be mostly aluminum that I will cut. I saw a 4kw PSU at goodluckbuy for $200 but I’m not sure if I can find something cheaper. What do you think?